We call Donavon on Thursday nights at 8:30 PM EST, 7:30 PM CST. We talk for 30 minutes and usually pass the phone around so everyone in the family can have a turn saying hello. We cover important details like, "What did you have for dinner tonight?" and "What did you do in school today?" and "Is it still hot down there?" We were excited to call him this week because he was coming off his personal best score since heading down to Runnymede in March (the boys there receive a weekly report that includes scores for school accomplishment, Bible memory and catechism, chores, physical education, and behavior. It's a pretty complex grid that they send out each week, I'm still trying to figure it out after 6 months!). I was sure he was going to be pretty hyped up -- eager to tell us all about it. One of his mentors always answers the phone and gives me a brief update on how his week has been. I could tell right away, things weren't going as well as we'd thought.
"We've noticed especially with the younger boys they tend to have a bad week coming off of a good one. Donavon's had a tough week, mostly in school. He's had Ditch two days in a row. In fact, he's finishing Ditch now. He's sitting on the tire while he talks to you. Here's your son. I hope you guys enjoy your phone call."
It's a big tractor tire and they have to flip it a number of times across a "ditch" along the side of the long driveway that leads up to Runnymede from the road. It's sort of the ultimate consequence for defiant behavior. I once asked Donavon, "What happens if you refuse to do it?" He said, "You can't refuse to do it. You have to do it." "Well, I mean what if a kid just said he wouldn't do it and night came?" "Then you'd just have to go to bed and as soon as you woke up, you'd have to go back to it."

I imagine him sitting there on the tire -- hot, sweaty, dirty, out of breath. "Hi Dad." His voice was down, broken, discouraged. But this was a slightly different voice than I've heard before. Usually in this case you'd hear anger in his voice, or perhaps a whining tone of injustice. This sounded more like remorse. I could be wrong. It might have been exhaustion. Perhaps he was homesick. Maybe just annoyed. In fact, I haven't heard remorse in Donavon's voice much in the 6 years I've been fathering him, so maybe I wouldn't recognize it anyway. That was one of the things that struck some fear in our hearts over the difficult years with Donavon. He was capable of some pretty awful things and we were occasionally successful at getting an apology out of him, but we never had a sense that he was remorseful -- you know, truly sorry for what he'd done, sad that he'd disappointed his parents, ashamed of falling short. These were the times you couldn't help but compare him to his siblings who understood when they'd let their father down. Some of them will burst into tears with merely a look of disappointment from their dad. But not Donavon.
There we were on the phone together -- me pacing up and down my driveway in Michigan and Donavon sitting on a dirty tire in southern Missouri. He was crying, weeping really, and I was trying to be a good dad in my 30 allotted minutes for the week, 730 miles away. I wanted to fly down there and sit on that tire with him and put my arm around him. If they were making a faith-based film about us I'd start helping him flip the tire through the ditch in slow motion with some country-pop Christian band playing an inspirational song. But, life isn't a faith-based film, not mine anyway. I had 30 minutes, well, by now more like 15 because I knew his sibs still wanted to say hi to him. This is our life now. This is a kind of parenting that you don't find in parenting books -- even in the appendix of one.
So, I fumbled around with what I hoped would inspire him to press on, fight the good fight of faith, go in the strength of the Lord. I said, "Donavon, you know the Lord is with you. You can ask him for the strength to do this and he will hear you." To which he replied, "It seems like when I pray the night before that I'll be good, I have a bad day the next day. But when I forget to pray I do better."
Gulp. Ok, now I'm down to 10 minutes. How can I assure this troubled boy who has had 9 rather unconventional and difficult years of life that all I've taught him about the Lord is indeed true and trustworthy? I was shocked by his observation about prayer actually. Donavon is a bright boy. He is capable of learning the right answers and he knows how to tell you what you want to hear. But the fact that he noticed this thing about his experience with prayer was a surprise to me. Is he really praying? Is he truly interacting with the triune God of the universe? Is he actually calling out to Him for help? What great hope that gives me. For I know that if he seeks, he will find. If he knocks, the door will be opened to him. If he asks, it will be granted him.
But what do I do with this observation. It's one I know all too well. I've asked the Lord for things, but it seems like sometimes he grants the opposite of my request. And certainly there are times I've been blessed without asking. In fact, I've been too bitter to ask, and yet, He has richly poured out blessing upon me. How many times did I plead with God to make the tantrum stop, only to have it intensify. I remember begging the Lord that he'd fall asleep, only to get another blood curdling scream in my ear. We've asked for peace, only to wake up to a war at our breakfast table. What's the use in praying? Is it effectual at all? So many of my prayers have gone unanswered. Well, seemingly unanswered. Or have they?
Donavon and I talked about the Lord working in mysterious ways. We talked about God asking Abraham to sacrifice Isaac, but Abraham having the faith to believe that God could raise Isaac from the dead if necessary. We talked about taking a step back and looking at the bigger view of things. There might be bad days here and there, even bad weeks, or bad months, or bad years in our lives, but God sees our WHOLE life. Even looking back to March, he should be able to see great progress. So, maybe it doesn't look like an answered prayer today, with today's issues happening right before your eyes. But if you take a step back, perhaps you can see the Lord working and answering.
This little struggle of Donavon's was hitting close to my heart. Raising Donavon and Kelvin sometimes feels like Ditch to me. It feels like a dirty, heavy tire. Flipping uphill. Just flipping. Over and over and over for no purpose other than to teach me a lesson. And how many times do I have to flip it before I learn the lesson? It seems like I should have learned it by now.
I said goodnight to him. He was still crying. I don't know if he was feeling any hope. I prayed for him. Our family gathered together, the little girls crying over their brother, and we prayed. In fact, when you only have 30 minutes/week to be a parent, you're often left with only one parenting tool -- prayer. And really, it's the best tool. I sat down and wrote Donavon a letter to follow up our brief conversation. I focused it on Psalm 126:
"When the Lord restored the fortunes of Zion, we were like those who dream. Then our mouth was filled with laughter, and our tongue with shouts of joy; then they said among the nations, 'The Lord has done great things for them.' The Lord has done great things for us; we are glad. Restore our fortunes, O Lord, like streams in the Negeb! Those who sow in tears shall reap with shouts of joy! He who goes out weeping, bearing the seed for sowing, shall come home with shouts of joy, bringing his sheaves with him."
This is what I told Donavon about the Psalm:
Here’s the story behind this Psalm. The Israelites were slaves in Babylon. The Lord sent them there because of their sin, but he sent them there with a promise that he would one day restore them -- bring them back to their home. When he finally did after many years, they could hardly believe it. They thought they were dreaming (verse 1). They became so happy, they were laughing uncontrollably and shouting with joy (verse 2)! They were so excited. Then, in verses 5 and 6 the Psalmist reminds them that they went to Babylon very scared, crying over their sin and wickedness. But God turned their tears into joy. He said it was like the tears were seeds put in the ground, but after much time, up came lovely fruit! It makes me think of the melons and tomatoes and potatoes and corn that you guys grow at Runnymede.
So, how does God bring us from crying about our sin to laughing with intense joy? Sin certainly isn’t funny. He does it through Jesus. Jesus is the way that weeping over our sin turns into joy over our salvation. But think about it. How would we appreciate the amazing joy and laughter that our salvation brings us if we didn’t FIRST have a time of sadness, crying, weeping? If we care about our sin, we’ll cry over it. Our sin is really awful, disgusting, and horrible. It should make us cry. If it doesn’t, then we probably don’t understand how truly terrible we are and how truly holy God is.
But, just as the seed over time grows into a lovely fruit that you can enjoy, your tears can turn into amazing joy in being saved, in being adopted into God’s family, being his son. So, Donavon, I’m not entirely sure what your tears were all about on the phone on Thursday, but I wonder if the Lord might be showing you your sin and it’s making you sad. Maybe not, maybe you were just angry, or tired, or frustrated. But I sensed that maybe you were understanding something about your sin. And if that’s true, then I’m confident that over time, you’ll know the joy of being saved. So, that’s why I said I was glad to hear you crying.
I'm just beginning to understand something about the Lord and suffering. It's starting to make some sense. It's ok to ask him for relief and it's good to ask. The Psalms are full of that. But, it's also good to learn to be content in your sufferings. In fact, we can find joy in them. I dare say, I might be finding some joy even now as I write this. There is much I have to be thankful for. It's easy to be thankful for my beautiful wife -- full of strength and wisdom. It's easy to be glad over my "typical" children who do well in school and make me proud in their athletic endeavors and performances. It's easy to be thankful for my comfortable home and my new (used) Jeep! But, I'm beginning to grow a deeper appreciation and now even a gratitude for the Lord's providence in bringing me pain. This pain is maybe, just maybe beginning to send a shoot up above the soil. The tears of sorrow that were planted have taken root. There are seedlings and there is hope that their will be choice fruit some day. I'm not naive. What looks like a lovely shoot early on could indeed sprout up to be a thistle. But even that will be a providence that produces a tear that can be sown and later reaped in joy.
It's my prayer that I'll bring that fruit to the wedding banquet of the King. I'll cut into it and among the multitude I'll hand a piece to Carissa, and Noah, and Natalie, and Francesca, and Maizy, and Louisa, and Kelvin, and Donavon. I'll watch him bite into it and see that big grin of his. And we'll all watch as his grin turns into a chuckle, and then a big, snorting, belly laugh! I imagine I'll look over his shoulder and see something off in the distance near one of heaven's trees, next to a ditch, perhaps with some tall grass growing over it since it hasn't been moved in a long while. Sure enough, it's that crazy Runnymede tractor tire. And I'll give a shout of joy.